Standing on the Fourth Hill Where an Empire Buried Its Dead
You are in the Fatih district, on the Fourth Hill of the old city, in the courtyard of a working Ottoman mosque. The building you have come to see no longer stands here. The Church of the Holy Apostles, for over seven centuries the second church of Constantinople after Hagia Sophia, was demolished by the Ottomans in 1461, and the Fatih Mosque — the Mosque of the Conqueror — was built on its site. What remains is an absence, and a story worth the detour: this was the imperial burial church of the Eastern Roman Empire, the place where most emperors, and many patriarchs and bishops, were interred and venerated for centuries. To visit is to stand where Constantine the Great was buried and where Justinian I built.
Trace a Lost Church Through Its Surviving Story
Nothing of the church survives above ground, so the visit is an act of reconstruction. Arm yourself with the sequence before you go:
- Constantine's foundation. Constantine dedicated the first church around 330, intending to gather relics of all the Twelve Apostles; in the event only relics of Saint Andrew, Saint Luke and Saint Timothy were acquired. He died before it was finished, and his son Constantius II completed it and buried his father's remains there. The grounds held a rotunda mausoleum built by Constantine and a cross-shaped church built soon after by Constantius — a plan that marked a landmark shift in Christian architecture, replacing the basilica plan with a centralized shrine plan, and was imitated in churches from Milan to Antioch and Aleppo.
- Justinian's rebuilding. By Justinian I's reign the church was judged no longer grand enough. A new Church of the Holy Apostles rose on the same site, designed by Anthemius of Tralles and Isidorus of Miletus — the same architects behind the rebuild of Hagia Sophia — and consecrated on 28 June 550. It was cruciform, surmounted by five domes: one above each arm of the cross and one above the central bay. Justinian added a mausoleum for himself and his family at the end of the northern arm.
- The relics and the treasure. The church's most treasured possessions were the skulls of Saints Andrew, Luke and Timothy. It also held what was believed to be part of the Column of Flagellation, to which Jesus had been bound and flogged, relics of Saint John Chrysostom and other Church Fathers, and huge amounts of gold, silver and gems donated by the faithful.
- The sack of 1204. The basilica was looted during the Fourth Crusade. The historian Nicetas Choniates records that the Crusaders plundered the imperial tombs for their gold and gems — not even Justinian's tomb was spared, and the tomb of Emperor Heraclius was opened and his golden crown stolen with his hair still attached. Some of these treasures were taken to Venice, where they can be seen in St Mark's Basilica.
- The last years. Michael VIII Palaeologus erected a statue of the Archangel Michael at the church after recapturing the city from the Crusaders, and Andronicus II Palaeologus partially restored it in the early 14th century, but it thereafter fell into disrepair. When Constantinople fell to the Ottomans in 1453, Sultan Mehmed II reassigned the church to the Orthodox Patriarch Gennadius Scholarius, and it briefly became the seat of the Ecumenical Patriarch — until 1456, when hostility in the neighbourhood drove the patriarchate to the Church of Theotokos Pammakaristos. The remains were demolished and the Fatih Mosque built on the site.
Make the Most of a Visit
Come knowing what you are looking for, and the site rewards you. Stand on the Fourth Hill and orient yourself as the church once did: it stood on the great thoroughfare called Mese Odós, the Central Street, in the newer part of the expanded imperial capital — which is why, despite ranking below Hagia Sophia in size and importance, it became the city's busiest church. Read the contemporary descriptions beforehand: the historian Procopius on Justinian's building, with its dome that "seems to float in the air and not to rest upon solid masonry"; the Crusader Robert de Clari, who in 1204 called it richer and nobler than Hagia Sophia; Nikolaos Mesarites, who praised its site as occupying "the place of the heart" of the Queen of Cities and described views from the upper galleries over the northern and southern seas. Because the church is gone, the highlight is the act of holding it in mind while you stand in the courtyard of what replaced it. Give the visit the time to do that rather than treating it as a quick stop.
What Else Is Close By
The site sits in the heart of the old city, so you can fold it into a wider day. The Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople, the patriarchate that briefly made its home in this very church, is a natural thread to follow. The great monuments of Sultanahmet — Hagia Sophia, the Blue Mosque, Topkapı Palace and the Süleymaniye Mosque — lie within the historic peninsula and reward a separate, unhurried visit. Each is a place in its own right; treat them as onward ideas rather than a checklist.
Start by reading the accounts of Procopius and Mesarites, then plan a morning on the Fourth Hill and let the Fatih Mosque's courtyard be your vantage point over a church that shaped a thousand years of architecture and buried an empire's emperors. The building is gone; the ground it stood on is not, and it is waiting for you to arrive knowing why it matters.